ive been messin around with some ideas for this website im makin for the club i work at, and i decided to make some spot light images, i think they look pretty good, but i need some opinions, so let me have it and let me know what you think

The red one doesn't look right to me, but its just an optical illusion I guess, I like the second one though.

the red one is more of the size i need it to be, i did notice that the backgound color isnt right, not much of a change but still has to be right

heres the change

The blue one has more of the classic spot light look to it.

both look good, the blue one is the better of the two

any opinions on how to make the red one look better, its more of the size that i need it to be, the blue was just a lucky first try

I like the blue!

go to selective color of photoshop and make the red more red lighter